Part 3 of 3

Over the past two weeks, we have followed Ridgeway O&P as it considers whether a hospital contracting opportunity fits the practice’s direction and what fulfilling it could require (part one, part two). Now the owner needs to decide what Ridgeway would be prepared to promise. Seeing the potential and identifying a plausible way to deliver the service are important, but the practice still needs to be able to support the commitment over time. 

I would approach that decision through three questions: What can Ridgeway afford, what must it protect, and under what conditions would it proceed? The answers should help the owner distinguish between terms the practice can support, terms that need negotiation, and terms it should decline. That moves the discussion beyond “we think we can make this work” to an explanation of what making it work would require. 

Establish what the practice can afford 

I would start with the resources Ridgeway would need to deliver the proposed service, rather than simply subtracting an additional employee’s compensation from expected revenue. Preparation, training, travel, coverage during absences, and administrative support all belong in the estimate, along with the owner’s time. Where existing employees would take on additional responsibilities, the cost of covering their current work needs to be included too. 

From there, I would separate the investment needed to get ready from the ongoing cost of providing the service. Ridgeway might need to spend money before payments begin arriving, so the owner should understand when costs would start, how they would be funded, and which needs of the existing practice must remain covered. The question is not simply whether the contract could eventually be profitable, but whether Ridgeway can support the path to that result without creating problems elsewhere in the business. 

Research offers a useful caution about treating growth itself as success: a study of more than 66,000 Finnish firms supported earlier findings that initial profitability was more important than initial growth in achieving high performance in both dimensions (Mansikkamäki, 2023). That does not establish a rule for an O&P practice or mean every investment must produce an immediate return. For Ridgeway, I would take it as a reason to explain how the arrangement would become financially sustainable, rather than assume additional volume will eventually make the numbers work. 

The owner can test that explanation against a slower start, lower post-discharge volume, or greater coverage demands than anticipated. A period of lower profitability may be reasonable if it is planned and funded. Before proceeding, though, the owner should be able to state how much Ridgeway is prepared to invest, how long it could sustain that investment, and what results would prompt reconsideration. Those answers establish the financial limits within which the proposal needs to work. 

Make existing commitments part of the conditions 

Financial limits are only part of the decision. Last week, we also considered hospital travel, schedule predictability, and the effect of added responsibilities on the team’s working lives (“Clarify the Commitment”). Those concerns now need to be addressed in the proposed arrangement. If a clinician would leave the clinic to provide hospital care, the owner needs to establish how existing appointments, documentation, and follow-up would be handled. The schedule may change, but the plan should not depend on fitting the same responsibilities into whatever time remains. 

The same applies to preparation and training. If the arrangement requires the current prosthetist to supervise or train someone, that work needs time in the schedule and a plan for the responsibilities it displaces. “We will find a way” leaves the practical decisions with the people already carrying the workload. Ridgeway needs to identify who will cover both the new responsibilities and the existing work before relying on that arrangement. 

The conversations with employees should help determine whether the plan is workable. Where someone has raised a concern about unpredictable hours or travel, the owner needs to return with a proposed arrangement and discuss whether it addresses the concern. Not every preference can be accommodated, but the decision should reflect what the owner has learned. The commitment to people should be evident in the schedule, coverage, and support provided, not simply in an assurance that their concerns were heard. 

Some additional demands during preparation may be reasonable, provided everyone understands what is being asked, for how long, and what would happen if preparation takes longer than expected. Those temporary demands should be distinguished from the normal operating arrangement. Ridgeway needs a credible way to serve the hospital without leaving existing patients or employees to absorb an unresolved gap in the plan. 

Write down the conditions for a yes 

Before submitting a proposal, I would bring these financial limits, service expectations, and commitments to the team together on one page. For each essential condition, record what must be in place, who is responsible for establishing it, and when it needs to be confirmed. That gives the owner a clear view of what is ready to support a promise and what remains unresolved. 

Suppose the arrangement would be workable only after someone has been recruited and prepared for the role. Ridgeway could make an achievable start date a condition of its proposal rather than promise immediate coverage and assume the current team will bridge the gap. If the hospital needs an earlier start, the owner would need either a credible alternative or a decision not to accept that timing. The condition has practical value because it changes what Ridgeway is prepared to offer. 

Some terms may be negotiable, while others may be necessary to keep the commitment within Ridgeway’s capabilities and financial limits. The owner should know which is which before discussions become focused on securing an agreement. Qualified legal and compliance advisers should review the proposed agreement and applicable requirements before a binding commitment is made. The owner’s management decision is whether the resulting terms meet the conditions the practice needs. 

Plan the review before the work begins 

Those same conditions should guide the review if Ridgeway begins providing the service. If the decision depends on a particular level of staffing, a defined investment, and a sustainable schedule, the owner needs a way to see whether those assumptions are holding. Before the work begins, agree on who will review service reliability, staff workload, financial performance, and patient-reported outcomes, and set dates to discuss the findings. 

Decide what would prompt action. Recurring overtime or cash use beyond the planned level should lead to a discussion about causes and corrections, rather than simply accepting the strain as part of the new work. The findings might call for changes in workflow, resources, or plans for further expansion. They do not erase existing patient or contractual obligations, so any response must account for the responsibilities Ridgeway has accepted. 

A deliberate yes, a deliberate no 

For Ridgeway, a sound decision could mean proceeding on terms the practice can support, negotiating unresolved conditions, or declining an arrangement that would ask more than it can responsibly provide. The conditions give the owner a basis for each of those choices. There is no need to decide in advance that success means winning the contract or avoiding the risk. 

Before your next significant commitment, try writing down the conditions under which you would be comfortable saying yes: what you can afford, what must remain protected, and what needs to be ready before you begin. That puts a practical boundary around growth without treating growth itself as a problem. The aim is to make a promise the practice can sustain, not merely win an opportunity it will have to find a way to manage. 

Next
Next

Clarify the Commitment